Sound Advice logo text

Audiologist vs. Hearing Aid Store: Which Gets Better Results?

Hearing Aids
Hearing Health
January 30, 2026
By
Dr. Ross Cushing

Key Highlights (TL;DR)

  • Hearing aids are tools, not comprehensive hearing treatment. Outcomes depend on how they’re evaluated, fit, and supported over time.
  • Audiologists diagnose and manage hearing health.
  • Many people who start at big-box or retail hearing centers later seek audiology care due to poor results.
  • Long-term follow-up, personalized adjustments, and clinical expertise are critical for hearing success.
  • Comprehensive audiology care, including comprehensive testing, evidence-based fitting (like Real-Ear Measurement), and ongoing care, often leads to better hearing, greater satisfaction, and fewer frustrations.

Short answer: If you're experiencing hearing loss, the real question isn't where to buy a hearing aid cheapest; it's where you'll receive comprehensive hearing healthcare that leads to the best outcomes. Hearing aid stores and retailers like Costco focus on selling devices. Audiologists focus on diagnosing, treating, and managing hearing loss over time, which is why patients who receive comprehensive audiology care typically achieve better long-term results.

Why Patients Ask: Audiologist or Hearing Aid Store?

When I sit with patients in my office, many of them already have hearing aids. What they’re frustrated by isn’t the device, it’s that they still can’t hear clearly in restaurants, family gatherings, or meetings. In almost every case, the issue isn’t motivation or effort; it’s the level of care they received along the way.

That’s because, over the last decade, hearing care has become more visible and more confusing at the same time. Big-box retailers, online companies, and hearing aid chains advertise convenience and lower prices, while audiology practices are often perceived as more medical and, sometimes, more expensive.

So it’s understandable for our patients to wonder:

  • "Do I really need an audiologist, or can I just go to Costco, Sam's Club, or a hearing aid store?"

It’s a fair question. Hearing aid stores are everywhere. They’re convenient. They often advertise lower prices. And for someone just starting to notice hearing difficulty, it can feel like the simplest place to begin.

But after years of caring for patients, I’ve learned that where people start isn’t nearly as important as where they end up. And many of the patients I see come to us after struggling with hearing aids they purchased elsewhere.

What an Audiologist Actually Does (That a Store Typically Doesn’t)

Chart displaying the key differences in features of an audiology practice and a retail or big box store that sells hearing aids.
Chart displaying the key differences in features of an audiology practice and a retail or big box store that sells hearing aids.

Audiologists are doctoral-trained healthcare providers who specialize in hearing, balance, and related disorders. Our role extends well beyond fitting hearing aids.

At Live Better Hearing + Balance, comprehensive audiology care typically includes:

I often tell patients that hearing loss rarely exists in isolation. It intersects with cognition, balance, communication, and overall quality of life. That’s why proper diagnosis and clinical oversight matter. This broader expertise matters, even if hearing aids are the initial reason for a visit to our office.

At Live Better Hearing + Balance, a meaningful percentage of our new patients come to us after purchasing hearing aids from retail stores or online—most commonly from Costco, Sam's Club, big-box retailers, and direct-to-consumer brands.

They're not starting over because the devices are defective. They're seeking help because they didn't receive comprehensive diagnostic care or evidence-based fitting in the first place.

Comprehensive Diagnostic Testing

Audiologist reviewing audiogram with patient after hearing exam
Audiologist reviewing audiogram with patient after hearing exam

Audiologists perform full diagnostic hearing evaluations, not just quick screenings. This includes testing that helps determine:

  • The type of hearing loss
  • The severity
  • Whether medical referral is needed
  • How the brain is processing sound

These details directly influence treatment decisions.

Identifying Medical Red Flags

Some hearing or balance symptoms require further medical evaluation. Audiologists are trained to recognize when hearing loss may be related to conditions that warrant referral to ENTs, neurologists, or other specialists.

Precision Hearing Aid Fitting

Best-practice audiology care includes Real-Ear Measurement, a verification process that measures how sound is delivered inside your ear canal. This ensures hearing aids are programmed accurately for your unique anatomy.

Many retail settings skip this step entirely.

What Are Audiology Best Practices?

Professional audiology organizations—including the American Academy of Audiology (AAA), American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA), and Academy of Doctors of Audiology (ADA)—recommend specific protocols for hearing aid fitting:

  • Comprehensive diagnostic testing (not just a basic screening)
  • Real-Ear Measurement to verify devices are programmed correctly for your unique ear anatomy
  • Counseling on realistic expectations and how the brain adapts to amplified sound 
  • Ongoing follow-up and adjustments as hearing changes over time
  • Coordination with physicians and specialists when medical issues are present 

These practices are standard in audiology clinics but uncommon in retail hearing aid settings.

Many of the clinicians at Live Better Hearing + Balance are part of Dr. Cliff Olsen’s HearingUp network, which recognizes providers nationwide who follow audiology best practices and the highest standards of hearing health care.

Counseling and Expectation Setting

Hearing is not instant or perfect even after a patient is initially fit with a hearing device. Audiologists spend time counseling patients on:

  • What hearing aids can and cannot do
  • How the brain adapts to sound
  • How to succeed in real-world listening environments

This guidance often determines whether someone succeeds or gives up.

Ongoing Care and Adjustments

Hearing typically changes over time. Audiologists provide long-term follow-up, fine-tuning, and support to ensure hearing aids continue to work well as life changes.

Audiology Practice vs. Retail Hearing Aid Store: Side-by-Side Comparison

To help you understand the key differences, here's a detailed comparison:

Feature Audiology Practice Retail/Big-Box Store
Provider Credentials Doctor of Audiology (Au.D.) and Hearing Instrument Specialists Typically Hearing Instrument Specialist (varies by state) or Audiologist
Diagnostic Testing Comprehensive evaluation Basic screening
Real-Ear Measurement Standard practice Rarely performed
Medical Coordination Coordinates with ENTs, PCPs, specialists Not available
Follow-Up Care Unlimited (typically 3 years) Limited (typically 1-2 visits)
Tinnitus Evaluation Available Not typically offered
Balance Testing Available at select locations Not available
Ongoing Adjustments Included (typically 3 years) May require additional visits/fees
Time Per Appointment 45-90 minutes 30-45 minutes
Patient Volume Lower, more personalized Higher, efficiency-focused
Note: This table represents general differences. Individual practices and retailers may vary. When choosing where to get hearing aids, consider the level of care and ongoing support you'll receive, not just upfront cost.

Why Hearing Aids Alone Don't Work Without Proper Care

Modern rechargeable hearing aids with advanced technology features
Modern rechargeable hearing aids with advanced technology features

A hearing aid is a piece of technology. Hearing care is a medical service.

In our practice, many patients arrive frustrated because hearing aids they purchased at Costco, Sam's Club, or other retail locations don't perform the way they expected. They tell me they still struggle in restaurants, miss parts of conversations, or feel fatigued from listening all day. 

Common issues include:

  • Devices that feel uncomfortable or unnatural
  • Difficulty hearing in noisy environments
  • Ongoing dissatisfaction despite multiple visits
  • Hearing aids that show premature wear or poor performance

When we dig deeper, the issue often isn’t the device itself. It’s what came before and what came after:

  • Limited or incomplete diagnostic testing
  • No verification that the hearing aids were properly programmed for their ears
  • Little to no follow-up care once the devices were dispensed
  • A lack of trust between patient and provider

Without addressing those factors, even advanced technology can fall short.

“Aren’t Audiologists Just More Expensive?”

Another hesitation I hear frequently is concern about cost or feeling pressured to buy.

Some people worry that seeing an audiologist will automatically be more expensive, or that the visit will turn into a sales pitch. I understand that skepticism.

Hearing aid prices at audiology practices may appear higher at first glance, but the comparison often overlooks what’s included. Audiology care typically bundles:

  • Comprehensive diagnostics
  • Professional fitting and verification
  • Follow-up visits and adjustments
  • Counseling and long-term support

At our practice, most hearing aids typically include long-term comprehensive hearing care included in the initial purchase, including consistent device care, unlimited office visits, ongoing adjustments, batteries (if needed), and future discounts on newer technologies. Over the life of the devices, this ends up being a far greater value for our patients.

Cost Comparison Example

While upfront pricing varies, here's what's typically included at each level of care: 

Retail/Big-Box Stores (e.g., Costco): $1,400-2,000 per pair

  • Includes: Basic hearing screening, device fitting, limited follow-up visits (typically 1-2), manufacturer warranty
  • Often excludes: Comprehensive diagnostics, Real-Ear Measurement, unlimited adjustments, medical coordination 

Audiology Practice: $2,500-6,000 per pair

  • Includes: Full diagnostic evaluation, Real-Ear Measurement-verified fitting, unlimited office visits, ongoing adjustments as hearing changes, supplies (batteries or chargers), coordination with physicians and specialists, long-term hearing health management
  • Total value over 5-year device lifespan: Often equal to or better than retail when factoring in comprehensive care 

The question isn't just upfront cost—it's total value, long-term outcomes, and whether you're receiving comprehensive hearing healthcare or simply purchasing a product.

In other words, lower upfront pricing on hearing aids may exclude ongoing care or rely on limited service models, increasing costs down the road.

What I can say is that good audiology care is about outcomes, not transactions. Many patients who initially choose lower-cost options later seek audiology care after experiencing poor results. At that point, they often wish they had started with comprehensive care earlier.

Why Ongoing Follow-Up Hearing Care Matters

Audiologist examining a pediatric patient with an otoscope
Audiologist examining a pediatric patient with an otoscope

Hearing loss is rarely static. Hearing can change gradually, and the brain’s ability to process sound evolves with age, health, and cognitive factors.

Successful hearing outcomes depend on:

  • Ongoing adjustments
  • Monitoring changes
  • Maintaining trust with a provider
  • Feeling comfortable asking questions and expressing concerns

Hearing aids don’t restore hearing on their own. They work best when paired with ongoing care, regular adjustments, and trust between patient and provider.

In my experience, the patients who do best are those who view hearing care as a process, not a one-time purchase. Over time, that approach leads to clearer communication, greater confidence, and a better quality of life.

Why Patients Come to Audiologists After Costco and Retail Stores

It’s more common than most people realize.

We routinely see patients who purchased hearing aids from Costco, Sam's Club, or other retail chains and later come to us for help

Sometimes they’re looking for a repair. Other times they simply say, “These just never worked the way I hoped,” or “They told me this was the best I could expect.”

When we evaluate those devices, we often find:

  • The hearing aids were never verified using Real-Ear Measurement
  • Programming doesn’t match the patient’s actual hearing needs
  • There’s been little adjustment over time as hearing changed

Price is often what drew them in initially. But many tell us that once they experience comprehensive audiology care, the long-term value becomes clear.

Real-Ear Measurement: The Gold Standard Most Retailers Skip

One of the biggest differences between audiology care and retail hearing aid sales is verification.

Audiologist performing Real-Ear Measurement hearing aid verification with probe tube in patient's ear
Audiologist performing Real-Ear Measurement hearing aid verification with probe tube in patient's ear

Real-Ear Measurement is considered the gold standard for hearing aid fitting. It measures how sound is actually delivered in your ear, not how a device performs in a test box or based on averages.

In my experience, patients are often surprised to learn that most retail hearing aid stores—including Costco and other big-box retailers—skip this step entirely. 

Without it, there’s no objective confirmation that the hearing aids are doing what they’re supposed to do.

Numerous studies show that REM leads to better speech understanding and higher patient satisfaction, and major audiological associations consider real ear measurement the gold standard in hearing aid fittings, including

What About Costco Hearing Aids?

This is one of the most common questions we hear, so it deserves a direct answer. 

What Costco Offers

Costco employs licensed hearing instrument specialists and, in some locations, audiologists. They offer competitive pricing on reputable hearing aid brands, and their return policy provides a safety net for customers. 

What Costco Doesn't Offer

However, Costco's business model prioritizes volume and efficiency over comprehensive clinical care. Based on our experience evaluating patients who started at Costco, many locations:

  • Only conduct basic hearing screenings rather than full diagnostic evaluations
  • Rarely perform Real-Ear Measurement to verify proper programming
  • Offer limited follow-up appointments (typically 1-2 visits)
  • Do not coordinate with ENTs, primary care physicians, or other medical providers
  • Focus primarily on device sales rather than ongoing hearing health management
  • Operate with high patient volume, limiting time for counseling and individualized care

When Costco Makes Sense

If you have straightforward, mild-to-moderate hearing loss, value price above all else, and don't anticipate needing ongoing clinical support, Costco may be sufficient for your needs.

When You Need More Than Costco

Many patients choose Costco initially due to pricing and convenience, then seek comprehensive audiology care when they experience:

  • Difficulty hearing in restaurants, meetings, or noisy environments despite wearing their devices
  • Discomfort or dissatisfaction that wasn't resolved in follow-up visits
  • Changes in their hearing that require more advanced clinical evaluation
  • Balance issues, tinnitus (either temporary or permanent), or other symptoms that warrant medical coordination

However, if you want:

  • Comprehensive diagnostic evaluation to understand the type and cause of your hearing loss
  • Evidence-based fitting using Real-Ear Measurement
  • Ongoing clinical support and adjustments as your hearing changes
  • Coordination with your physicians for complete, integrated care
  • A long-term relationship with a provider who knows your hearing health history

...then a dedicated audiology practice will typically provide better outcomes. The choice isn't just about cost. It's about the level of clinical care you're receiving and whether it will lead to successful long-term hearing outcomes.

A Note for Adult Children and Caregivers

Image of Dr. Jenifer Cushing, Doctor of Audiology & co-founder of Live Better Hearing + Balance
Dr. Jenifer Cushing, Doctor of Audiology & co-founder of Live Better Hearing + Balance

Adult children and caregivers often play a critical role in helping someone seek care.

I’ve seen many situations where a spouse or adult child researched hearing loss and read patient experiences, then gently encouraged a loved one to see an audiologist. 

When caregivers understand the difference between device sales and comprehensive hearing care, they’re better equipped to guide that decision.

Many caregivers report better outcomes when their parent works with an audiologist who:

  • Takes time to explain options
  • Coordinates care with physicians
  • Provides ongoing support rather than one-time solutions

That support often leads to earlier intervention and better long-term outcomes.

So, Which Option Is Right for You?

If your goal is simply to buy a device, have very mild hearing loss and value convenience above all else, a hearing aid store may seem sufficient.

But if your goal is to hear better in the moments that matter, understand what’s happening with your hearing, and receive care that adapts as your needs change, an audiologist provides a level of expertise and support that a retail model can’t replicate.

An audiologist is typically the better choice if:

  • Hearing loss is impacting daily life
  • Speech understanding is difficult
  • There are balance or tinnitus concerns
  • Previous hearing aids haven’t worked well
  • Long-term outcomes matter

Choosing care is about more than buying a device. It’s about choosing a partner in your hearing health.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a referral to see an audiologist?

In most cases, no. Many patients can schedule directly with an audiologist.

Is an audiologist a real doctor?

Yes. Audiologists earn a Doctor of Audiology (AuD) degree and are licensed healthcare providers.

Why do hearing aids cost more at audiology practices?

Pricing often includes professional services, follow-up care, and long-term support, not just the device itself.

Is seeing an audiologist more expensive than a hearing aid store?

Not necessarily. While initial costs may differ, comprehensive care and proper fitting often reduce long-term frustration and replacement costs.

Can an audiologist help if I already have hearing aids?

Absolutely. Many patients seek audiology care to improve hearing aids they purchased elsewhere — including from Costco, Sam's Club, or online retailers.

We can:

  • Test whether your current devices are programmed correctly for your hearing loss
  • Perform Real-Ear Measurement to verify they're delivering appropriate amplification
  • Make adjustments to improve speech clarity in challenging listening environments
  • Evaluate whether the devices themselves are appropriate for your degree and type of hearing loss
  • Coordinate with your physician if underlying medical issues may be contributing to hearing difficulty

Many patients who bring in hearing aids purchased elsewhere experience meaningful improvement once the devices are properly evaluated and adjusted using audiology best practices.If the devices are inadequate for your needs, we can discuss better options.

A note on fees: Most audiology practices, including ours, charge a one-time onboarding or evaluation fee when providing care for hearing aids purchased elsewhere. This fee covers the time required for comprehensive diagnostic testing, device evaluation, reprogramming, and clinical documentation. 

This is standard practice in healthcare, similar to how physicians charge for evaluations and treatment even when addressing conditions diagnosed elsewhere. The fee ensures you receive the same thorough, professional care as patients who purchased their devices from us, and it reflects the clinical expertise and time required to optimize your hearing outcomes.

If you decide to upgrade to new hearing aids through our practice, this fee is often applied as a credit toward your purchase.

I bought hearing aids at Costco and they're not working well. Should I return them or see an audiologist?

If you're within Costco's return window (typically 180 days), you have options: 

  1. Return them and seek comprehensive audiology care if you want a fresh start with full diagnostic testing and evidence-based fitting.
  2. Bring them to an audiologist for evaluation if you'd like to see whether they can be optimized before making a decision. We can determine if the devices are appropriate for your hearing loss and whether proper programming might resolve your frustrations.

Many patients are surprised by how much better their Costco hearing aids perform after receiving Real-Ear Measurement and proper adjustments from an audiologist. However, if the devices themselves are insufficient for your needs, we'll let you know honestly. 

Either way, you deserve to hear well. Don't settle for "good enough" if you're still struggling.

Can an audiologist work with my primary care doctor or ENT?

Yes. Audiologists regularly collaborate with physicians to ensure complete, coordinated care.

What if I’ve been told my hearing “isn’t bad enough”?

Early care can still make a meaningful difference, especially in noisy environments or social settings.

Can audiologists help with balance or dizziness?

Yes. Many audiologists specialize in vestibular and balance evaluations and work closely with other medical providers.

Final Thought

Hearing aids can help you hear sounds again. Comprehensive audiology care helps you hear life again – clearly, comfortably, and with confidence over time.

If you're exploring your options, the most important question isn't "Where can I buy hearing aids cheapest?" It's "Where can I receive comprehensive hearing care that leads to the best long-term outcomes?"

For most people, that answer is a dedicated audiology practice.

If you're experiencing hearing difficulty, schedule a comprehensive evaluation with a doctor of audiology. If you live in Maryland, Virginia, Pennsylvania, or New Jersey, one of our doctors of audiology or hearing specialists would be happy to see you, and you can schedule an appointment at one of our clinics. The difference in outcomes is worth the investment.

Medical Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Consult with a licensed audiologist or physician for personalized hearing healthcare recommendations tailored to your individual needs.

Chief Executive Officer
Read More

Written by Dr. Ross Cushing

Ross Cushing, Au.D., is the Chief Executive Officer at Live Better Hearing + Balance. Dr. Cushing has been a clinical audiologist for nearly 20 years and chief leader of Live Better Hearing + Balance since 2007, where he believes that it is only through a combination of kindness and competency that we can achieve success with our practice and our patients.

Chief Learning & Development Officer and Audiologist
Read More

Reviewed by Dr. Jenifer Cushing

Dr. Jenifer Cushing is the Chief Learning & Development Officer of Live Better Hearing + Balance and an audiologist in the Frederick, MD clinic. Dr. Cushing earned a Bachelor of Arts in Hearing & Speech Science from the University of Maryland, College Park and a Doctorate in Clinical Audiology from the University at Buffalo.

More from the blog